Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Douglas Brodie's avatar

Aside from the disastrous economic consequences of Net Zero, last Wednesday’s lunar eclipse of the sun gave an unseen demonstration of how fragile our electricity grid has become and how vulnerable we are to being unable to power the grid in adverse conditions, as the following facts and figures clearly show.

I used Richard Lyon’s real-time Grid Margin tool to monitor the fuel mix feeding the grid at 5 minute intervals over the period of the eclipse.

The grid operator NESO put out a special advance notice telling gas power stations to be ready to ramp up their supply.

The following paragraph is an edit of my original which mistakenly claimed that interconnector supply had been deliberately curtained by NESO because it could not be relied upon in uncertain conditions, which critics have been saying for years.

International interconnector supply going into the eclipse was only 3% which was low but not unprecedented. Solar supply duly waned from 16% to 2% over the period and gas supply rose from 39% to 47% to carry the load, with other minor supply and demand changes. No problemo, thanks to wind holding steady at just under a chunky 20%, but no great achievement either considering that we get a total eclipse of the sun every night.

But what will happen in future Dunkelflaute periods of no sun and no wind when, as seems very possible, our gas and nuclear supplies have been allowed to wither away relative to the postulated Net Zero increase in demand for electricity?

Conversely, even if baseload nuclear and dispatchable gas supplies are maintained and expanded as they ought to be to cope with future demand eventualities when there is no sun (which didn’t fully disappear during the eclipse) and no wind (which was strong and steady during the eclipse), with Dunkelflaute conditions extending into Europe resulting in minimal interconnector supply (as during the eclipse), all this occurring in cold dark midwinter (when the demand for power is much higher than at this time of year) - pause for breath: then what on earth is the point of all those redundant, ruinously-expensive, instability-inducing, short lifespan, resource-depleting, non-recyclable, China supply-chain/slave-labour dependent, dangerously-low ERoEI solar and wind renewables; and international interconnectors which we can’t rely on; and a nationwide carpet of battery systems with only enough storage to feed the grid for about 10 minutes?

Only a fool or a liar can claim that these so-called renewables, which aren’t at all green or sustainable, are having any discernible impact on “tackling climate change”. The UK government recently let the cat out of bag by admitting that after all our painful community/landscape/farmland-despoiling strivings to reduce emissions, over the years from 1996 to 2023 UK net greenhouse gas emissions fell by a paltry 15%: https://www.gov.uk/government/statistics/uks-carbon-footprint/carbon-footprint-for-the-uk-and-england-to-2023.

And of course the UK now only contributes a falling (thanks mainly to deindustrialisation) 0.8% of total world CO2 emissions which conversely continue to increase steeply year-on-year as shown in this graph: https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/annual-co2-emissions-per-country?country=GBR~OWID_WR~OWID_WRL.

And of course the latest Statistical Review of World Energy published by the Energy Institute shows that for the world as a whole, 2025 total world energy was 86.2% supplied by hydrocarbons (oil, gas, coal), an unbridgeable energy chasm away from Net Zero. For the UK, 2025 total energy was 78.9% supplied by hydrocarbons, not much better than the world average for all our 30 years of zealous obeisance to Net Zero which has only been paid lip service by most of the rest of the world.

It is clear that in engineering terms, as opposed to make-believe “global energy transition” propaganda terms, Net Zero is a mega globalist fantasy which is going nowhere, very slowly: https://www.energyinst.org/statistical-review.

And these inconvenient facts are before even broaching upon the fact that honest physics calculated by honest independent scientists proves that CO2 emissions pose negligible risk of dangerous global warming because the “warming effect” of atmospheric CO2 molecules is already almost saturated.

Meanwhile, the USA Trump administration has withdrawn from the corrupt United Nations' pernicious and pointless Net Zero and Agenda 2030 and has emphasised their stance by declaring that “globalisation is dead”. Highly-populous India and Indonesia are examples of how the majority rest of the world are powering ahead their economies based a hydrocarbon-powered future, with no regard for Net Zero: https://co2coalition.org/2026/08/11/indonesia-and-india-are-jointly-planning-a-hydrocarbon-powered-future/.

There are no valid environmental, economic, energy security or moral grounds for the UK to continue pursuing unilateral Net Zero, especially when it is clearly getting nowhere other than to severely damage and deindustrialise the economy due to sky-high energy prices - or is that the covert plan?

Net Zero needs to be abandoned, along with Agenda 2030. We need to reconfigure our national energy infrastructure based on solid scientific and engineering principles, for example as set out by energy analyst Richard Lyon: https://richardlyon.substack.com/p/chapter-7-forging-a-new-realism.

I personally don’t trust the Conservatives after all the tyrannical oppressions they have inflicted on us over the years, but here’s a report they have commissioned describing their totally new approach to Net Zero which would save hundreds of billions of pounds: https://notalotofpeopleknowthat.wordpress.com/2026/08/19/new-report-says-milibands-clean-power-plan-will-cost-320-billion/.

Mitch's avatar

Insane. You said it yourself David. Absolutely insane! Yet miliband and his successor are blindly going around as if they are doing no wrong whilst driving our country into the ground. Nobody, on any TV channel, or anywhere it seems has the balls to challenge them when they keep spouting verbal diarrhoea about how cheap renewable energy is. It's utterly INSANE!

82 more comments...

Ready for more?